The Herd by Emily Edwards
Bryony and Elizabeth are best friends and despite being polar opposites, their friendship works. They live for their families and each other, they are godmothers to each other's daughters, trusting that the safety of their children is paramount. But some things have gone unspoken between them, they differ radically over one very important issue, and when Bryony, afraid of being judged, tells what is supposed to be a harmless white lie before a child's birthday party, the consequences are catastrophic.Bryony grew up with a severely autistic brother whose autism their mother believes stemmed from the MMR vaccine, so she vows never to vaccinate Alba. Elizabeth's daughter, Clemmie, cannot be vaccinated due to an early childhood illness and so the family rely on others to maintain herd immunity in order to keep her safe.
Elizabeth, Bryony and other characters - a doctor, a journalist, a mother, an internet troll, all take their turn at being sympathetic, informative, sanctimonious and annoying. The callousness of the internet and media is skilfully captured.
This is a profound, emotional read, based on contentious issues of vaccination and herd immunity, but it does so in a way that doesn't preach for either side, it highlights the pain that may be experienced by those making their choice on either side of the debate. It feels honest, fair, and doesn't shy away from any of the arguments frequently thrown up about vaccines.
This is a profound, emotional read, based on contentious issues of vaccination and herd immunity, but it does so in a way that doesn't preach for either side, it highlights the pain that may be experienced by those making their choice on either side of the debate. It feels honest, fair, and doesn't shy away from any of the arguments frequently thrown up about vaccines.
Despite being very sad, it’s an excellent read.
∼ Happy Reading∼
Polly x
This sounds very interesting and nice to hear that there's no preaching in it.
ReplyDeleteIt is very well written
DeleteIt certainly addresses a timely subject.
ReplyDeleteVaccination is always a diverse subject.
DeleteSounds good. I'm sure vaccination is an interesting issue with all that's happening with vaccines these days.
ReplyDeleteLove,
Janie
The MMR was very controversial. when it was first introduced.
DeleteSounds like such an emotional and timely read! I like that the book tackles both sides of the vaccine debate without preaching and shows the real struggles people face when making tough choices. . Adding this to my reading list—it sounds powerful!
ReplyDeleteIt is very emotional and powerful, there is an argument for both decisions.
DeleteThis sounds like a deeply engaging and thought-provoking read. The nuanced approach to such a contentious topic is commendable, and it’s fascinating how the characters each bring their own perspectives to the story.
ReplyDeleteI just shared a new travel post, please read: [https://www.melodyjacob.com/2024/10/visit-dumbarton-castle-scotland-historic-fortress-dunbartonshire.html] Thank you.
It is very good the way it portrays the fors and against vaccination.
Delete